Bartolino’s The Hill Reviews
At Bartolino’s The Hill, we’re proud to welcome guests for lunch, dinner, celebrations, and group gatherings, then hear them talk about the food, the service, and the atmosphere long after the meal is over. Here’s what our guests are saying about The Hill, in their own words.
Short on Time? Start Here
★★★★★
“As always, a tremendous dining experience. Very accommodating to my better half with her mobility scooter. Everyone was friendly from the hostess to the server to the general manager to the owner Chris. Always a pleasure to dine at Bartolino’s The Hill or Bartolino’s South County. Never a bad dining experience and always quality food.”
Steven
★★★★★
“Such an exciting, vibrant experience. Our server Rocky managed our large group with ease. Always there when anyone needed something and anticipated our needs.”
Diane
★★★★★
“Food was fantastic. Very large portions. Staff was great, and the owner went out of his way to ensure that all guests were enjoying themselves. Definitely will be coming back.”
Constantijn
★★★★★
“We reserved the big room for a family party of 24. Our servers, Rachel and Harrison, did a fabulous job.”
Laura
★★★★★
“Lively vibe with live music, a good selection on the kids menu, and a great selection of wines. Everything you need for a relaxing family dinner.”
Serge
Food Guests Come Back For
“This is the spot to go if you enjoy Italian food.”
“Excellent food at a very affordable price, a great atmosphere, and top-notch service. This is the spot to go if you enjoy Italian food. My dinner partners had the Salmon Salad, which was enormous, and the Farfalle Primavera. I had the Tortellini con piselli. Overall, an excellent location. I’ll go back.”
Jakob
“Pork chops are the best in town.”
“Such an exciting, vibrant experience. Our server Rocky managed our large group with ease. Always there when anyone needed something and anticipated our needs. After flavorful appetizers of toasted ravioli and Sicilian toasted ravioli, we knew we were in for a wonderful meal. Pork chops are the best in town. No need for a knife, they are so tender. The house risotto is almost as good as Momma makes. Sole al ferri and salmon carciofi are excellent choices if you are craving a fish meal. For pasta, the angel hair Roseanne has shrimp and scallops in an amazing sauce. Highly recommend to anyone wanting a great meal and excellent service.”
Diane
“My lunch at Bartolino’s today was amazing.”
“My lunch at Bartolino’s today was amazing. Bread and butter were served first. Our waiter refilled our waters obsessively. I got the Chicken Wrap with housemade chips. The wrap was so good. A great balance of sweet from the caramelized onions and tangy, salty flavor from the Caesar dressing. The chips were so good. Light, airy, and crispy with just a dusting of Parmesan cheese and light seasoning. So good. I always order house chips from restaurants. These are the best I’ve ever had.”
Valerie
“They have the best pizza in St. Louis.”
“I’ve only ordered pizza here. In my humble opinion, they have the best pizza in St. Louis. You might pay a little more, but it’s well worth it.”
Jim
“Linguine Tutto Mare with marinara is too good for words.”
“I go there for every St. Louis visit. It’s our favorite place. Linguine Tutto Mare with marinara is too good for words.”
Cary
“The sole was magnificent.”
“Excellent lunch. We had an attentive, competent, and efficient waiter. The sole was magnificent. Loved the bread on the table.”
Suzanne
At Bartolino’s The Hill, we want guests to leave remembering a full meal, not just one dish. These reviews reflect the kind of food experience we work to deliver every day: classic Italian favorites, generous portions, strong lunch and dinner options, and signature dishes people look forward to ordering again.
Dinner at The Hill
“Had another excellent birthday dinner here.”
“Had another excellent birthday dinner here. Great service, good atmosphere, and terrific food with generous portions. We ordered calamari and risotto balls for appetizers, Tutto Mare with two different sauces, and a shrimp pine nut pasta.”
M
“Excellent food and atmosphere.”
“Excellent food and atmosphere. I look forward to my next visit.”
Greg
“Amazing food and service.”
“Amazing food and the staff and service are almost as good as the food. Highly recommend. Make a reservation.”
Jay
“As always, a tremendous dining experience.”
“As always, a tremendous dining experience. Very accommodating to my better half with her mobility scooter. Everyone was friendly from the hostess to the server to the general manager to the owner Chris. Always a pleasure to dine at Bartolino’s The Hill or Bartolino’s South County. Never a bad dining experience and always quality food. Thanks again to the entire staff for making me look good with my two friends dining with me. Very much appreciated!”
Steven
“We loved dining here.”
“We chose to have our happy hour drinks here, and we chose to have dinner here, too. Service was excellent. The bartender deserves a raise, she was great. We split a steak and sides, which were delicious. The last night we dined there, I had the scallops and risotto, and it was amazing. We loved dining here.”
Tish
At Bartolino’s The Hill, dinner should feel worth the trip, whether it is a date night, a birthday, or a family meal you have been looking forward to all week. These reviews show the kind of evening experience our guests count on us to deliver.
Exceptional Service at The Hill
“Our server Rocky managed our large group with ease.”
“Such an exciting, vibrant experience. Our server Rocky managed our large group with ease. Always there when anyone needed something and anticipated our needs.”
Diane
“The hosts are amazing.”
“The hosts are amazing. They made sure to take care of us. We will definitely be back.”
Nicole
“Top-notch service.”
“Excellent food at a very affordable price, a great atmosphere, and top-notch service. This is the spot to go if you enjoy Italian food.”
Jakob
“They made our family celebration that much more special.”
“We reserved the big room for a family party of 24. Our servers, Rachel and Harrison, did a fabulous job. They were patient, checked on us without being a nuisance, and accommodated some latecomers by adding onto the end of one of the big tables. The food was fresh, delicious, and brought out hot, not lukewarm. Some of our party even ordered dessert. Xavier did a great job of bussing the table and grabbing extra drinks. Considering how many people we had, I felt like it was a good deal price-wise as well. Thank you, Bartolino’s, for making our family celebration that much more special.”
Laura
“The waiter was a really nice and helpful guy.”
“The waiter was a really nice and helpful guy. We were a bit underdressed because we didn’t know what we were walking into, but they didn’t say anything and treated us just as well as anyone else. The food was absolutely excellent. We had the seafood risotto, one of the best things I’ve ever eaten, and the rigatoni pesto, which was exquisite and complex for a pesto. Definitely would recommend, and definitely going again sometime.”
Gretchen
“Everyone was friendly from the hostess to the owner.”
“As always, a tremendous dining experience. Very accommodating to my better half with her mobility scooter. Everyone was friendly from the hostess to the server to the general manager to the owner Chris.”
Steven
At Bartolino’s The Hill, service is one of the clearest ways we show guests who we are. These reviews speak to the hospitality we care about most: attentiveness, warmth, patience with groups, and a team that helps every table feel comfortable and well looked after.
Atmosphere at The Hill
“Such an exciting, vibrant experience.”
“Such an exciting, vibrant experience. Our server Rocky managed our large group with ease.”
Diane
“Lively vibe with live music.”
“Lively vibe with live music, a good selection on the kids menu, and a great selection of wines. Everything you need for a relaxing family dinner.”
Serge
“Great atmosphere.”
“Excellent food at a very affordable price, a great atmosphere, and top-notch service.”
Jakob
“Looked great.”
“Excellent choice by friends. They told us it was a recent remodel of the restaurant, and it looked great. We shared a wedge salad, and the table had a risotto, chicken parm, and chicken Michael. All delicious.”
David
“A relaxing family dinner.”
“Lively vibe with live music, a good selection on the kids menu, and a great selection of wines. Everything you need for a relaxing family dinner.”
Serge
At Bartolino’s The Hill, the room matters as much as the meal. We want guests to feel the energy of the restaurant while still enjoying a comfortable, polished setting that works for celebrations, family dinners, and nights out that feel a little more special.
Private Dining and Group Celebrations
“A nice separate room for a group of 21 people.”
“We were there and had a nice separate room for a group of 21 people. People loved their food. Our server did a great job.”
Tom
“Had a family function and it was a 5-star experience.”
“We had a family function, and it was a 5-star experience. Service was great, atmosphere was great, and the food was amazing. Highly recommend this place and hope to be back again soon.”
Matt
“Very accommodating and easy access.”
“As always, a tremendous dining experience. Very accommodating to my better half with her mobility scooter.”
Steven
“We reserved the big room for a family party of 24.”
“We reserved the big room for a family party of 24. Our servers, Rachel and Harrison, did a fabulous job. They were patient, checked on us without being a nuisance, and accommodated some latecomers by adding onto the end of one of the big tables. The food was fresh, delicious, and brought out hot. Considering how many people we had, I felt like it was a good deal price-wise as well.”
Laura
“They graciously accommodated our group.”
“We had a large party of 35 to 40 people, and they graciously accommodated our group. Family friendly, the food was delicious, and the private enclosed patio ambiance was on point, perfectly complementing the beautiful weather.”
Mo
At Bartolino’s The Hill, we’re proud to host private dining events, family parties, and larger group celebrations that deserve smooth service and a strong meal from start to finish. These reviews give a real picture of the group experience we aim to create.
Drinks, Wine, and Cocktails
“We chose to have our happy hour drinks here.”
“We chose to have our happy hour drinks here, and we chose to have dinner here, too. Service was excellent. The bartender deserves a raise, she was great.”
Tish
“A great selection of wines.”
“Lively vibe with live music, a good selection on the kids menu, and a great selection of wines. Everything you need for a relaxing family dinner.”
Serge
“Excellent food and wine.”
“Excellent food and wine. We sat near the servers’ station, and they were all over us.”
Vickie
“The bartender deserves a raise.”
“Service was excellent. The bartender deserves a raise, she was great.”
Tish
“Great music in the bar.”
“Excellent food and wine. Great music in the bar.”
Vickie
At Bartolino’s The Hill, drinks are part of the full night out. These reviews show guests noticing the wine, happy hour, cocktails, and bar experience that help make dinner feel even more complete.
Want the Same Experience?
At Bartolino’s The Hill, we want every guest to enjoy memorable Italian food, warm hospitality, and a setting that feels right for everything from a casual meal to a larger celebration. These reviews offer a look at the experience we work to deliver every day.
Quick Links
Bartolino's The Hill Hours
Call to Order: (314) 644-2266
